1435765369 0.0.0.0 r=red 1435765370 0.0.0.1 r=red 1435765665 0.0.0.2 r=red 1435765680 0.0.0.3 r=wut 1435765733 0.0.0.4 r=wut 1435765753 0.0.0.5 r=red 1435765775 0.0.0.6 r=red 1435765819 81.99.216.21 r=red 1435765915 108.233.127.43 r=red o=Of course, the labels can be inconsistent or lying, regardless. :-) 1435765948 74.71.69.240 r=wut 1435766061 82.132.231.173 r=wut 1435766087 207.251.103.46 r=wut 1435766188 104.132.34.66 r=wut 1435766531 216.165.225.102 r=wut 1435766546 200.118.194.177 r=red 1435766594 200.118.194.177 r=other o=Did you mean "the treasure is NOT in this box" for green? Otherwise this is obviously red. 1435766649 107.77.75.76 r=red 1435766790 134.161.116.3 r=red 1435766835 79.77.27.104 r=red 1435766977 207.251.103.46 r=red 1435767061 68.109.199.39 r=red 1435767143 157.166.167.129 r=red 1435767150 207.251.103.46 r=red 1435767200 50.136.171.192 r=wut 1435767234 91.215.118.214 r=wut 1435767235 54.240.197.225 r=red 1435767297 64.121.172.235 r=red 1435767314 72.14.227.238 r=red 1435767319 64.121.172.235 r=wut 1435767327 91.195.1.33 r=red 1435767333 50.168.104.133 r=wut 1435767355 80.189.60.254 r=red 1435767383 144.15.255.227 r=red 1435767401 96.37.2.19 r=green 1435767442 173.14.129.9 r=red 1435767445 24.22.134.241 r=wut 1435767511 213.126.55.74 r=wut 1435767544 80.223.123.73 r=red 1435767651 50.79.106.117 r=other o=test post 1435767707 68.40.166.33 r=red 1435767715 70.88.241.233 r=wut 1435767732 71.241.240.34 r=red 1435767830 128.210.206.145 r=green 1435767857 79.216.135.75 r=red 1435767999 78.32.231.9 r=red 1435768022 97.92.25.165 r=red 1435768114 108.20.78.175 r=red 1435768201 158.82.202.5 r=red 1435768252 109.190.124.23 r=red 1435768271 204.124.18.195 r=red 1435768279 69.203.156.178 r=red 1435768386 217.140.96.140 r=other o=If both statements were constrained to be either true or false, then the treasure would have to be in the red box (only G false permits R to be nonparadoxical). But there is no such constraint. I can put the treasure in whichever box I like, and then write any confusing sequence of words I feel like on the box labels, without any force of nature requiring the assignability of a well defined truth value to my scribblings. 1435768387 38.140.30.218 r=wut 1435768389 64.73.254.82 r=red 1435768450 94.234.170.177 r=red 1435768506 204.124.18.195 r=wut 1435768559 151.48.2.108 r=other o=I got stuck in a "this sentence is false" problem. I'd pick Red just because. 1435768566 151.48.2.108 1435768626 75.119.222.136 r=red 1435768639 75.76.19.18 r=wut 1435768656 80.194.40.229 r=green 1435768819 71.67.244.143 r=red 1435768928 64.72.83.16 r=red 1435769122 131.187.75.138 r=other o=If we assume a universe where the metaphysics demands that the labels on boxes somehow constrain reality then I'll go for the red one. If, however, the universe is one where people can just stick labels on boxes willy-nilly, well then, there is not enough information to determine the answer. 1435769129 100.10.21.51 r=wut 1435769145 24.125.71.94 r=red 1435769170 194.138.12.171 r=red 1435769209 66.109.232.162 r=red 1435769248 64.242.52.33 r=wut 1435769269 5.71.114.134 r=red 1435769434 80.194.40.229 r=green 1435769448 108.18.139.7 r=other o=ASSUMING the labels actually relate to the contents and each other, the treasure is in the red box 1435769501 209.77.138.10 r=red 1435769547 76.115.12.93 r=other o=There is no treasure. Both labels are lying. Look at those boxes. Do you really think someone put a treasure in one of them just for this logic puzzle? 1435769572 78.25.120.190 r=red 1435769645 185.30.53.225 r=red 1435769746 207.251.103.46 r=wut 1435769836 188.108.213.179 r=red 1435769913 108.48.124.82 r=green 1435769975 74.125.57.102 r=red 1435770086 109.104.48.200 1435770123 77.109.141.138 r=wut 1435770276 128.197.72.135 r=red 1435770276 107.77.70.17 r=other o=If the labels are meaningful, it's in red but that hasn't been established. 1435770472 186.90.254.13 r=red 1435770640 172.56.38.175 r=red 1435770833 38.96.153.66 r=red 1435770960 66.218.46.190 r=red 1435771051 66.241.32.158 r=red 1435771134 82.225.80.2 r=red 1435771205 207.251.103.46 r=red 1435771271 75.149.106.130 r=red 1435771321 118.71.186.2 r=red 1435771370 66.249.84.195 r=wut 1435771407 86.111.137.155 r=red 1435771516 73.172.62.28 r=wut 1435771547 176.10.249.246 r=red 1435771553 216.252.90.163 r=red 1435771605 140.221.8.198 r=wut 1435771840 73.149.246.216 r=red 1435771858 181.169.198.88 r=red 1435771865 181.169.198.88 r=green 1435771869 181.169.198.88 r=wut 1435771900 88.87.234.68 r=red 1435772078 86.132.28.81 r=red 1435772088 185.79.100.86 r=red 1435772271 86.28.144.137 r=red 1435772353 98.176.120.243 r=red 1435772472 208.55.254.110 r=red 1435772504 94.41.241.179 r=wut 1435772538 86.20.79.135 r=red 1435772545 190.75.233.158 r=red 1435772612 85.94.120.221 r=red 1435772784 204.176.49.45 r=red 1435772790 98.196.205.229 r=red 1435772810 71.177.221.146 r=wut 1435772831 173.11.42.174 r=red 1435772867 198.151.161.131 r=red 1435773063 76.99.13.88 r=wut 1435773216 2.64.117.38 r=red 1435773344 97.84.195.71 r=red 1435773362 50.249.210.221 r=red 1435773535 59.167.226.54 r=red 1435773604 198.45.18.20 r=wut 1435773605 187.121.0.72 r=red 1435773715 94.41.241.179 r=wut 1435773904 65.127.80.66 r=wut 1435774123 93.40.109.11 r=wut 1435774215 173.9.84.1 r=red 1435774248 66.228.162.32 r=green 1435774272 72.246.0.10 r=wut 1435774312 66.249.84.207 r=wut 1435774331 88.96.136.14 r=red 1435774334 71.177.221.146 r=red 1435774387 70.81.138.180 r=red 1435774397 37.11.173.13 r=red 1435774503 138.246.2.179 r=red 1435774520 179.159.10.143 r=red 1435774601 199.64.6.154 r=red 1435774627 50.74.229.50 r=red 1435774648 75.144.111.205 r=red 1435774689 190.216.244.214 r=wut 1435774756 66.249.81.207 r=red 1435774844 178.27.240.113 r=wut 1435774971 98.212.196.254 r=wut 1435774996 71.177.221.146 r=red 1435775065 79.192.111.138 r=red 1435775099 65.166.0.15 r=red 1435775167 216.223.243.218 r=red 1435775228 70.36.190.2 r=red 1435775229 74.209.24.237 r=wut 1435775472 199.116.243.67 r=red 1435775516 204.191.180.139 r=other o=there is no treasure 1435775586 37.123.160.77 r=wut 1435775598 84.196.177.73 r=wut 1435775704 82.230.173.59 r=other o=I see what you did there 1435775712 186.167.242.236 r=red 1435775790 190.74.100.210 r=red 1435775916 74.202.210.6 r=red 1435776121 83.202.45.94 r=red 1435776232 71.122.217.50 r=red 1435776333 95.90.203.241 1435776334 95.90.203.241 1435776334 95.90.203.241 1435776334 95.90.203.241 1435776403 80.30.158.39 r=red 1435776416 86.145.192.23 r=wut 1435776694 86.9.104.28 r=wut 1435776803 89.69.196.246 r=red 1435776812 89.69.196.246 r=red 1435776867 89.69.196.246 r=red 1435777039 68.102.26.42 r=red 1435777117 91.2.87.33 r=red 1435777208 81.56.82.173 r=red 1435777445 71.14.217.50 r=red 1435777492 72.88.91.115 r=red 1435777563 216.59.106.66 r=other 1435777832 82.2.129.35 r=red 1435778052 31.147.119.221 r=other o=Nobody can figure out which box contains the treasure using only labels on them, since there is no connection between labels and contents of the boxes for all we know. 1435778225 212.198.99.247 r=wut 1435778241 104.132.34.68 r=wut 1435778264 80.119.67.24 r=red 1435778275 80.119.67.24 r=red 1435778294 86.172.91.97 r=red 1435778332 213.205.251.100 r=red 1435778828 80.202.123.181 r=other o=There is nothing stopping anybody from putting a treasure in any box, and attaching any labels they want. So it could be either. 1435778886 62.131.228.205 r=wut 1435779125 221.120.249.114 r=red 1435779307 83.92.25.101 r=red 1435779478 216.220.172.16 r=red 1435779594 46.222.96.183 r=green 1435779638 137.69.117.203 r=red 1435779653 95.211.174.103 r=red 1435779672 146.198.91.123 r=red 1435780290 98.140.201.137 r=red 1435780410 92.57.66.104 r=red 1435780453 5.18.55.114 r=red 1435780525 109.158.157.35 r=wut 1435780556 98.159.211.247 r=red 1435780608 174.92.123.63 r=wut 1435780723 74.121.28.6 r=red 1435780809 128.2.71.226 r=red 1435780943 198.151.61.245 r=red 1435781153 172.56.12.17 r=wut 1435781304 76.104.240.179 r=red 1435781511 86.145.194.9 r=red 1435781908 107.77.70.120 r=wut 1435781931 174.108.42.52 r=wut 1435782037 97.88.247.106 r=red 1435782068 205.175.226.96 r=wut 1435782173 92.107.104.155 r=red 1435782577 66.62.244.5 r=red 1435782617 80.44.231.243 r=red 1435782947 46.5.2.238 r=red 1435783010 87.251.137.19 o=14 Jan 2014 ... 1st studio siberian mouses nk022_learn_to_suck M_23 Masha smoking MSH_45 1435783508 111.69.227.186 r=red 1435784130 108.243.2.74 r=wut 1435784205 83.170.70.50 r=red 1435784252 194.177.246.103 r=red 1435784304 199.241.200.78 r=wut 1435784489 31.18.56.54 r=red 1435784592 96.52.250.254 r=red 1435784605 80.223.185.189 r=wut 1435784797 162.129.251.87 r=red 1435784936 54.240.196.169 r=red 1435784956 54.240.196.169 r=green 1435785043 35.0.127.52 r=red 1435785236 50.247.84.234 r=red 1435785380 192.76.8.22 r=red 1435785570 54.209.60.63 1435785617 86.22.248.60 r=wut 1435785651 78.60.58.6 r=red 1435785668 199.116.175.55 r=other o=Unstated assumptions. In one case, we have a true label and a false label. In the other, we have a true label and a self-contradictory label. Why should we prefer one over the other? 1435785836 95.222.242.86 r=red 1435785850 217.92.195.175 r=red 1435786070 75.150.180.10 r=wut 1435786072 62.24.181.135 1435786218 54.240.196.169 r=wut 1435786315 4.30.136.90 r=red 1435786449 71.241.240.34 r=red 1435786806 158.121.107.32 r=red 1435787113 98.16.212.93 r=wut 1435787315 173.166.123.129 r=red 1435787354 66.187.239.16 r=red 1435787581 199.172.169.79 r=wut 1435787768 104.172.125.243 r=red 1435787827 65.190.131.233 r=red 1435788111 75.25.61.154 r=red 1435788114 220.244.149.147 r=red 1435788570 74.77.138.146 r=red 1435788599 124.35.203.1 r=red 1435789172 70.194.135.232 r=red 1435789317 94.254.198.50 r=red 1435789509 89.29.97.130 r=green 1435789534 59.100.131.197 r=wut 1435789839 118.208.96.17 r=wut 1435790276 97.35.64.123 r=wut 1435790359 178.190.50.71 r=red 1435790364 178.190.50.71 r=wut 1435790841 54.240.196.185 r=wut 1435790985 73.190.72.21 r=wut 1435791455 24.112.240.17 r=red 1435791475 73.25.217.110 r=wut 1435791830 187.176.243.19 r=red 1435791831 99.17.34.65 r=red 1435791845 82.153.21.1 r=wut 1435792037 137.147.188.209 r=red 1435792162 68.196.41.51 r=red 1435792183 99.251.250.160 r=red 1435792673 87.118.63.60 r=red 1435792945 203.86.205.69 r=red 1435793203 139.80.32.101 r=red 1435793436 54.240.196.169 r=red 1435793780 130.195.253.48 r=red 1435794589 65.36.82.150 r=red 1435794635 46.44.34.52 r=wut 1435794641 175.156.175.168 r=wut 1435794680 103.1.240.1 r=red 1435794689 103.1.240.1 r=green 1435795098 126.236.7.31 r=red 1435795163 155.94.176.72 r=other o=http://www.houzz.com/pro/dcalvo/denise-calvo-interiors 1435795348 199.7.157.53 r=red 1435795733 66.87.117.31 r=green 1435796256 96.41.168.110 r=red 1435796803 62.198.186.20 r=red 1435796965 50.46.144.225 r=red 1435797021 188.179.206.129 r=wut 1435798670 24.21.205.185 r=red 1435798759 187.127.70.163 r=green 1435799289 106.185.38.177 r=wut 1435799505 108.81.81.205 r=wut 1435799817 145.97.215.93 r=red 1435800077 81.53.133.106 r=red 1435800321 87.231.134.42 r=wut 1435800393 1.64.220.57 r=red 1435801158 50.111.19.250 r=red 1435801764 64.180.185.31 r=red 1435801764 66.27.85.18 r=red 1435801784 66.27.85.18 r=red 1435802242 77.247.138.43 r=wut 1435802712 177.138.87.134 r=red 1435802952 79.148.157.137 r=red 1435803001 147.11.252.42 r=other o=Given that we have no reason to believe the statements given by the labels are either meaningful or trustworthy, the labels might as well be nonsense; and so one might as well ignore the statements about the labels. So all one can say is determined by the first two sentences; given those, all we know is that at least one of the boxes contains a treasure. 1435803638 66.249.83.165 r=other o=http://lesswrong.com/lw/ne/the_parable_of_the_dagger/ 1435803980 49.205.91.66 r=red 1435804091 71.20.42.132 r=other o=It can be either box, but I want to make sure you know that I really understand the puzzle 1435804216 144.118.242.115 r=red 1435804944 71.204.90.28 r=wut 1435805019 68.49.180.74 r=green 1435805873 67.188.141.107 r=wut 1435806379 71.164.209.119 r=red 1435806516 97.124.243.99 r=red 1435807247 75.72.220.226 r=red 1435807341 99.236.51.46 r=wut 1435808508 68.108.254.28 r=red 1435808711 50.177.28.37 r=wut 1435808926 99.113.38.248 r=wut 1435809138 76.102.240.137 r=wut 1435809219 24.61.186.101 r=red 1435809295 71.201.11.159 r=red 1435809896 71.252.251.115 r=green 1435810742 107.167.113.60 r=wut 1435810835 84.246.166.21 r=red 1435811801 50.250.223.109 r=red 1435813251 203.49.69.44 r=red 1435813338 50.174.152.246 r=red 1435813632 104.2.178.21 r=wut 1435814048 54.241.198.78 1435814395 104.34.144.31 r=red 1435814664 195.222.76.139 r=red 1435815036 190.75.233.158 r=wut 1435815099 174.92.123.63 r=red 1435816247 188.65.156.34 r=red 1435816566 82.239.65.141 r=red 1435817122 217.42.217.186 r=red 1435817804 82.100.10.65 r=wut 1435818275 92.32.223.98 r=green 1435819365 125.239.166.140 r=red 1435819412 192.176.1.92 r=red 1435819893 84.56.52.12 r=red 1435820639 66.75.69.217 r=wut 1435820712 195.243.219.118 r=red 1435821275 134.58.46.112 r=wut 1435821452 86.5.215.226 r=red 1435821592 81.18.187.196 r=red 1435821641 184.23.134.121 r=red 1435821697 79.98.220.4 r=other o=the problem is inconsistent 1435821706 89.176.55.40 r=red 1435822753 213.106.83.248 r=wut 1435822954 139.165.223.19 r=wut 1435822963 78.50.25.175 r=red 1435822964 207.81.55.179 r=red 1435823161 213.119.3.11 r=wut 1435823195 192.109.190.88 r=red 1435823496 203.49.69.44 r=wut 1435823832 83.247.136.72 r=wut 1435823854 93.187.88.19 r=red 1435824118 88.119.17.198 r=red 1435824128 93.31.10.245 r=red 1435824533 85.195.224.130 r=wut 1435825085 130.225.20.51 r=red 1435825812 88.105.198.113 r=red 1435826087 78.142.138.4 r=wut 1435826467 31.221.100.54 r=red 1435826922 195.89.19.114 r=wut 1435827623 91.206.0.43 r=wut 1435828257 31.221.1.56 r=red 1435828311 193.40.6.84 r=red 1435828533 82.100.10.65 r=red 1435828539 82.100.10.65 r=red 1435828777 114.76.85.222 r=wut 1435829806 131.111.184.18 r=other o='--; DROP TABLE ANSWER 1435831410 122.248.182.57 r=red 1435831903 147.83.68.7 r=red 1435833191 138.37.88.225 r=green 1435834282 80.110.26.250 r=wut 1435834490 80.110.26.250 r=red 1435834723 80.110.26.250 r=red 1435834763 87.142.128.134 r=red 1435834815 92.236.58.208 r=red 1435834981 88.68.198.187 r=red 1435835323 77.78.86.225 r=red 1435835330 77.78.86.225 r=red 1435837493 15.203.169.107 r=red 1435837657 202.83.101.185 r=red 1435837755 91.183.92.221 r=wut 1435838006 212.250.148.138 r=red 1435838262 89.47.17.161 r=wut o=http://www.buzzfeed.com/petradimovski/the-alkaline-diet-a-diet-which-makes-sense-18len 1435838343 217.91.125.204 r=red 1435839715 84.92.209.222 r=red 1435840658 133.9.4.18 r=red 1435840813 84.203.238.90 r=red 1435840833 167.107.191.217 r=red 1435841295 98.193.0.60 r=red 1435841800 87.81.226.211 r=wut 1435841903 80.110.26.250 r=wut 1435841934 80.110.26.250 r=red 1435841973 68.82.223.81 r=red 1435843939 178.162.211.218 r=red 1435844259 72.92.88.10 r=red 1435844313 41.60.88.110 r=red 1435844652 73.202.50.46 o=Either the treasure is in the green box and there's a Barber's Paradox, or it's in the red box and zero or one of the labels is true. 1435845709 193.104.159.132 r=green 1435846217 80.222.155.162 r=wut 1435846642 24.124.89.145 r=red 1435846665 149.172.82.0 r=wut 1435847325 217.189.169.61 r=other o=logic maldefined 1435847850 86.165.36.246 r=red 1435848070 193.108.184.61 r=red 1435848340 68.196.33.219 r=wut 1435848605 195.169.141.54 r=red 1435848687 202.79.203.99 r=red 1435849704 91.218.68.239 r=red 1435849886 103.31.214.78 r=red 1435849940 206.167.137.20 r=red 1435850488 209.234.229.67 r=red 1435850619 194.185.43.12 r=red 1435851047 79.223.49.18 r=red 1435852044 24.154.117.48 r=red 1435852064 24.154.117.48 r=wut 1435852078 80.47.83.215 r=red 1435852222 80.47.83.215 r=wut 1435852325 77.172.231.193 r=red 1435852531 129.21.187.14 r=red 1435853483 208.97.209.158 r=red 1435853504 195.88.229.20 r=red 1435853518 195.88.229.20 r=wut 1435853628 173.14.129.9 r=red 1435853964 75.25.117.204 r=red 1435854282 75.168.116.192 r=red 1435855212 173.164.241.93 r=red 1435855292 105.208.162.156 r=green 1435855449 199.246.40.54 r=red 1435855835 68.198.36.60 r=red 1435855929 24.129.29.95 r=red 1435856413 56.0.143.23 r=green 1435856497 108.52.158.48 r=red 1435857368 181.164.124.139 r=red 1435857649 80.1.38.187 r=red 1435857843 129.162.1.213 r=wut 1435857973 162.17.190.121 r=wut 1435858436 134.36.154.190 r=red 1435859303 192.241.188.92 r=red 1435860489 87.79.78.105 r=other o=if the treasure is in the green box then the statement on the red box label is self-contradictory, but absent any constraints on the truth values of the statements, it is unclear whether that means anything ---ap 1435861805 82.170.122.211 r=red 1435862356 83.43.71.158 r=red 1435863289 128.63.64.33 r=wut 1435863835 95.72.48.18 r=red 1435863925 204.153.104.254 r=red 1435864469 184.23.159.2 r=wut 1435865415 78.54.91.64 r=red 1435865518 93.0.249.226 r=red 1435865655 99.137.158.207 r=wut 1435865762 132.150.226.76 r=wut 1435865786 132.150.226.76 r=wut 1435865909 86.28.254.38 r=red 1435866695 134.84.150.191 r=red 1435868523 186.188.6.88 r=red 1435868578 66.249.93.240 r=red 1435869710 190.136.197.181 r=red 1435873374 63.152.77.115 r=wut 1435874429 79.136.60.114 r=red 1435874456 79.136.60.114 1435874459 79.136.60.114 r=red 1435874941 84.246.166.21 r=red 1435875024 188.214.55.168 r=green o=http://getgamesforfree.com/ 1435876043 167.160.110.89 r=green o=http://Support.Google.com/plus/answer/40695?hl=en 1435876181 107.167.112.217 r=red 1435876630 71.224.125.130 r=wut 1435879796 203.87.162.4 r=red 1435880920 207.21.18.3 r=red 1435882127 138.88.67.25 r=red 1435882835 192.240.208.131 r=wut o=http://hummingbirdtattoo.org/hummingbird-tattoo-cherry-blossom-tattoo-their-meanings 1435884614 108.84.166.39 r=wut 1435885181 93.215.186.52 r=red 1435890766 50.143.153.151 r=red 1435890994 188.210.213.143 r=other o=http://dermexclusivevsmea.wix.com/dermmeningfullbeauty 1435891091 24.130.188.227 r=red 1435893131 96.232.96.103 r=red 1435895969 172.56.21.57 r=red 1435898277 46.117.193.125 r=red 1435898283 46.117.193.125 r=red 1435899302 95.31.134.143 r=red 1435907442 137.92.65.62 r=red 1435909782 84.175.72.249 r=wut 1435909876 129.13.72.197 r=wut 1435910697 138.88.71.149 r=red 1435910704 138.88.71.149 r=wut 1435911415 217.155.192.11 r=red 1435911516 73.222.120.136 r=red 1435911871 77.102.43.162 r=red 1435912025 217.155.192.11 r=wut 1435912148 147.127.122.13 r=red 1435913569 87.246.78.46 r=wut 1435913990 144.32.240.24 r=red 1435914995 109.146.118.203 r=red 1435915764 81.155.83.76 r=wut 1435915789 195.88.229.18 r=red 1435915800 141.113.85.93 r=wut 1435917448 195.221.0.34 r=red 1435917724 195.59.191.91 r=wut 1435918091 141.163.219.49 r=red 1435919020 160.45.168.136 r=red 1435920853 193.240.8.2 r=red 1435921792 110.175.13.23 r=wut